Indie Games Winter Uprising Quality Analysis
Tuesday, December 21, 2010
By: Matthew Doucette


Indie Games Winter Uprising

Of what quality are Indie Games Winter Uprising (IGWU) games, so far?

Disclaimer:

We are an IGWU member with Decimation X3. Also, I want to make it clear that the IGWU was never about an elitist nature nor an assumption that all IGWU games are better than all non-IGWU games across the board. In fact, I believe our non-IGWU game, is better than our IGWU game, released two days apart.

Hypothesis:

Ok, let's jump into it. I believe the IGWU selection process was excellent and produced a selection of very high quality XBLIG games. A look at the stats will show us if this is true. The stats were collected from the U.S., as they sell the most XBLIG games of any country, on December 21st, 2010 at 11PM GMT-4 timezone.

The Games:

Here are the games. The links go to developer websites. To download the games visit indiegames-uprising.com.

The Ratings:

Here are the games' ratings, from highest to lowest:

  • (5 star rating, ranking of 1,521 games = title)
  • 4.5, 6th = Epic Dungeon
  • 4.5, 12th = Aphelion 2
  • 4.25, 13th = ZP2KX: Zombies & Pterodactyls!
  • 4.25, 17th = radiangames Crossfire 2
  • 4.25, 22nd = Soulcaster II
  • 4.25, 24th = Score Rush (originally selected for IGWU until we pulled it)
  • 4.25, 25th = Decimation X3
  • 4.0, 42nd = Chus Dynasty
  • 4.0, 49th = Hypership Out of Control
  • 4.0, 60th = Break Limit
  • 3.25, 290th = Asteroids Do Concern Me
  • 3.25, 399th = Ubergridder

Missing IGWU games are unreleased. In comparison, the median XBLIG game is 2.75 stars and 760 out of 1,521. I included Score Rush as it was initially selected for IGWU. It was removed from IGWU by our call, and therefore its removal was outside of the selection process. Keep in mind the selection process was done pre-release.

Note: As Greenstone Games pointed out in the App Hub Forums:

I think readers ought to keep in mind that ratings are a little distorted for the first week or two of release. Over time they settle.

IGWU vs. My Digg-Style 3.5+ Star Promotion Idea:

A comparison of IGWU to my 3.5+ promotion idea was raised, so I'll address it here. It comes out as follows: Based on the stats above, all but two IGWU games would have been selected for advanced promotion. Next, had my Digg-style idea been in place, here are the games that would have received extra promotion. I will highlight IGWU selected games:

  • Vertigo
  • Aphelion 2 (IGWU)
  • ZP2KX (IGWU)
  • Lunacy
  • Santa And The Zombie Encounter
  • radiangames Crossfire 2 (IGWU)
  • Osr unhinged
  • 8 Ball Pool Champion
  • Kozu
  • Toy Stunt Bike
  • Drum Studio: Platinum Edition
  • Soulcaster II (IGWU)
  • Avatar Bump!
  • Switch!
  • Football Games Room
  • Chus Dynasty (IGWU)
  • Score Rush (was IGWU)
  • Decimation X3 (IGWU)
  • Tile Trip
  • Fish Hunter
  • SIRTET
  • Curse of the Crescent Isle
  • Zombie Accountant
  • Break Limit (IGWU)
  • Epic Dungeon (IGWU)

Nine out of twenty-five games were IGWU selections. That's over one third of all the 3.5+ star XBLIG releases in this current range. As said earlier, only two IGWU games would not make the 3.5+ star cut. You can make a subjective call on if the IGWU games were better selections than the other 3.5+ star games. Keep in mind a few things: Most of these games did not ask to be included in IGWU, as well as the comparison between IGWU and my proposed Digg-style idea is actually meaningless. The IGWU is developer created, where the Digg idea can only be created by Microsoft. Both are inspired by developers, but only one can be accomplished by developers. I think IGWU and the proposal to Microsoft for the Digg-style idea, together, were both great things for XBLIG and do not overlap or compete with one another.

Conclusion:

The selection process behind IGWU was extremely well done. It's hard to find any fault at all in this process. The two lowest rated games in the IGWU are actually very high quality and polish despite not receiving as much love from gamers at large. I do not feel that they impacted IGWU negatively at all, and was happy to have Decimation X3 released right beside Asteroids Do Concern Me (love that title!), one of the two games. So, kudos to IGWU. Job very well done (and still going).

 

More Indie Articles:

2016/Jul/21 Practicing Self-Care as an Entrepreneur
2016/Jul/06 Ego is the Enemy
2016/Jul/05 XNA 5.0 Officially Declined by Microsoft
2016/Jun/28 Kickstarter: Xydonia: Action Packed Japanese Inspired Retro Shmup
2016/Jun/06 Unity Game Development Tutorial
2016/Mar/25 2D Game Development Tutorial - Part 1 - Installing the Software
2016/Mar/17 Introducing Xona Learn
2016/Mar/17 2D Game Development Tutorial - C#/XNA (PC/X360/PS4/XB1)
2015/Dec/02 Maenam by Jami Sieber (Braid Soundtrack)
2015/Nov/08 A Little Bit of Indie Game Dev Philosophy
2015/Sep/28 Xbox LIVE Indie Games (XBLIG) Tribute
2015/Sep/23 Mommy's Best Action Pack Released On Steam!
2015/Sep/09 The Official End Dates of XBLIG Announced
2015/Aug/17 Support XBLIG Backwards Compatibility on Xbox One!
2015/Jun/16 This is Phil Fish
2015/Apr/09 Two Canadian Kickstarter Games
2014/Oct/01 Explained: Touhou vs. Doujin
2014/Sep/19 Google Adsense
2014/Aug/16 Halifax Scramble S (Wrap Up)
2014/Aug/10 How Many Games Does a Game Developer Own?
2014/Aug/04 Kickstarter: Elysian Shadows, a Next-Gen 2D RPG
2014/Jul/25 Kickstarter: Funded Viridis, an Indie Shmup
2014/Jun/06 Alexander Bruce: Inspirational Indie Developer
2013/Sep/03 Kickstarter: Funded Mighty No. 9!
2013/Aug/27 Take Risks
2013/Aug/19 XBLIG Love: A Look to the Past for a Better Future
2013/Jul/25 Indie Royale's Indie Gamer Chick Bundle
2013/May/27 Blockt: Underrated XBLIG Puzzle Game
2013/May/20 Sad News on Radiangames' First F2P, Bombcats
2013/May/02 Funded Another Retro Kickstarter: Chasm
2013/Apr/29 Two Cool Kickstarter Projects
2013/Apr/23 PAX East 2013 Wrap Up
2013/Apr/10 Kickstarter: Shmup Devs Unite!
2013/Feb/28 Braid Explained
2013/Jan/31 Antichamber Launches Today!
2013/Jan/28 Don't Stop
2013/Jan/12 Honoring Seumas McNally
2012/Dec/19 Why Braid Has a Speed Run
2012/Nov/04 Gateways: One of the Best XBLIG Games Ever
2012/Jun/25 Game Prototyping
2011/Jul/27 Xbox LIVE Indie Games Should Be Doing More
2011/Jul/22 Xona Games Backs Indie Game: The Movie On Kickstarter
2011/Jun/08 Photoshop: How To Delete Off-Canvas Content
2011/Jan/05 Revolver360 Top Xbox LIVE Indie Game in Japan
2010/Dec/30 Vote to Include Indie Games in "Best of 2010" Xbox LIVE Dashboard Promotion
2010/Dec/29 Indie Game Winter Uprising Featured on Xbox LIVE Dashboard
2010/Dec/21 Indie Games Winter Uprising Quality Analysis
2010/Dec/08 xWMA with XACT in XNA Game Studio 3.1
2010/Dec/06 Microsoft, We Need More Than 50 XBLIG Tokens!
2010/Dec/01 XBLIG Top Rated & Best Selling Country Lists
2010/Nov/30 Indie Games Winter Uprise Trailer
2010/Nov/18 Indie Games Winter Uprising
2010/Nov/17 Improve Traffic Flow to XBLA and XBLIG: More Proposed Changes to Xbox LIVE Dashboard
2010/Nov/15 Xona Proposal: Changing the Face of XBLIG: Proposed Changes to XBLIG Dashboard (Final Draft)
2010/Nov/10 Xbox LIVE, Where Have My XBLIG Ratings Gone?
2010/Nov/05 Windows Phone 7 Emulator & Fraps Color Problem
2010/Nov/04 Why We Should Encourage "Crap" XBLIG Games
2010/Nov/02 XBLIG Dashboard Worries Continued...
2010/Nov/01 Changing the Face of XBLIG: Proposed Changes to XBLIG Dashboard (First Draft)
2010/Oct/22 The 1st Annual "Who's An Indie Gamer?" Poll Survey
2010/Jul/29 Game Rain #1 - Win 1 of 21 Xbox LIVE Indie Games
2010/Jul/20 Mark Rein's Apology w/ Great Indie Advice
2010/Jul/19 New Xbox LIVE Indie Games Roundup Show
2010/May/24 Top 50 Xbox Forum Communities in XBLIG
2010/May/17 Indie Inspiration
2010/May/04 Great Indie Game Developer Advice
2010/May/03 Multidirectional XNA Games Control Tip
2009/Dec/20 MIGS 2009 Wrap Up

 

 

About the Author: I am Matthew Doucette of Xona Games, an award-winning indie game studio that I founded with my twin brother. We make intensified arcade-style retro games. Our business, our games, our technology, and we as competitive gamers have won prestigious awards and received worldwide press. Our business has won $180,000 in contests. Our games have ranked from #1 in Canada to #1 in Japan, have become #1 best sellers in multiple countries, have won game contests, and have held 3 of the top 5 rated spots in Japan of all Xbox LIVE indie games. Our game engines have been awarded for technical excellence. And we, the developers, have placed #1 in competitive gaming competitions -- relating to the games we make. Read about our story, our awards, our games, and view our blog.



Home | Games | Awards | About | Learn | Blog | Press Kit | Contact
Email:

Xona Games, Xona.com, Xonatech, Saw Tooth Distortion, Evolutionary Prototype (EP), Duality ZF, Decimation X, Decimation X2,
Decimation X3, Decimation X3.5, Decimation X4, Score Rush, Score Rush 2, Score Rush (HTML5), Score Rush MP, and Score Rush Extended (Score Rush EX)
trademarked and copyrighted by Xona Games Inc., Matthew Doucette, and/or Jason Doucette.
© 2000..2005 Saw Tooth Distortion. © Xona.com. © 2008..2010 Xona Games (under Xona.com).
© Xona Games Inc.

We make Intense Retro video games.